Lisa Diemer

Lisa Diemer
4.91/5 out of 224 reviews

Committed to inspiring and protecting dreams in COLUMBUS, Ohio.

Call (614) 488-9445
Proud to be an American Star certified agencyExcellence in Customer Experience

Our Agency

amy miller profilephoto
Amy Miller
Non-Licensed Staff

Since joining the Lisa Diemer Agency in Fall 2022, I’ve supported the team with organization and customer service. As admin and marketing specialist, I schedule appointments and boost client engagement. Outside work, I enjoy time with my husband, twi

caitlin rutten profilephoto
Caitlin Rutten
Non-Licensed Staff

Caitlin Rutten is a seasoned marketing expert who loves memes, puns, and helping amazing people find the Lisa Diemer Agency.

janet marie profilephoto
Janet Marie
Customer Service Representative

I have been a licensed assistant to Lisa for over 25 years and enjoy helping clients with their insurance needs. In my personal life, I cherish spending time with my family, listening to audio books and always enjoy a good laugh. My family and I ar

a person with long hair
Lisa Faytle
Customer Service Representative

With 25+ years in insurance, I’m proud to serve as a licensed Property & Casualty agent at the Lisa Diemer Agency. I help customers understand coverage and make informed choices. I’m detail-oriented, creative, and dedicated to personalized service. O

thomas kiszla profilephoto
Thomas Kiszla
Customer Service Representative

With 25+ years as a Senior Personal Lines Underwriter, I bring deep industry knowledge to my role as Assistant Agent at American Family Insurance. I’m passionate about helping people protect what matters and making insurance easy to understand. Outsi

shield divider

What do you want to protect?

AgentWebsiteReviews

JSS component is missing React implementation. See the developer console for more information.

people on ledge

Ask me about

A man in a driver's seat with a woman in the passenger seat smiling at each other

Contact my office

We're here to help answer your questions!

Please take a moment to complete the contact form and my office will be in touch with you soon.